Friday Night Lights: “New York, New York”
6 March 2009
by R.A. Porter
You’ll be swell! You’ll be great!
Gonna have the whole world on the plate!
Starting here, starting now,
Honey, everything’s coming up roses! – Mama Rose
So ends Six’s story, with the tearful reunion of an accidental family and the broken heart of a lifelong friend. Nothing ever could stop Jason Street, not even a broken neck. So while yes, the kid with the GED getting even an entry level job at a New York boutique agency is a bit crazy, I can *almost* believe it. Scott Porter is that good. He’s so good, I could watch Jason lie outright to Wendell about being on his way back to Dillon and stopping in just to help the poor kid make the right decision and *still* believe every word he said.
That’s a testament to Street as a character and Porter as an actor.
Jason rolls off into the sunset on $40K a year and the knowledge that he’ll be running that agency someday. At least he should know that.
While I expected Porter’s always stellar performance to bring the money in that final scene, it was really the perfect reaction shot on Tim that pushed me over the edge. In a season where he’s already shown remarkable growth as a performer, Taylor Kitsch did more with his silent expression to close out the episode than he’s done in three years on the show.1 Tim still has his brother and Lyla, but his BFF, his blood brother, is gone from his life now. Those miles represent more than distance. They represent life paths.
Meanwhile, back in Dillon, practice continues apace.2 Frustrated by receivers who can’t run their patterns, Matt asks Coach if he can demonstrate. He runs the route, catches the pass, and causes Mac McGill’s heart attack. What? You thought that was coincidental? No way. We all know Mac’s feelings on white athletes and black athletes. Learned that the hard way back in season one. Nope. Mac had a heart attack because he realized subconsciously that Matt Saracen – his fleet of mind but slow of foot QB – was going to become a WR for the Dillon Panthers. Dropped him on the spot.
Not that it should have. Coach is a stubborn man. No way was Coach Eric Taylor going to risk playing his backup QB as a receiver. No way was…right. Julie wins the day with her powers of nagging. She persisted and persuaded and droned on enough at that dinner table that Coach knew the only way to stop her was to give Matt an impromptu tryout. So back to the street where Julie once proved her arm to her father for Matt to prove his legs to his surrogate father.3
So Matt’s got a new position, JD’s got a new favorite target, Tim’s so good at tailback he doesn’t need to practice, there’s an Aikman taking Mac’s spot, and the Dillon Panthers are *doomed*. Seriously? This isn’t a juggernaut, this is a Flag Football D-League team at this point. I mean, I’m glad the show is generally back and hitting its marks well. Emotionally, I’m on board with everything. But the football decisions? Crap.
As for our other two story fronts…
We got to watch Tyra make yet another incredibly stupid decision, primarily because the last person she talked to before heading out for her interview was her mother. Had she spoken with Tami before going over, she’d probably have aced the interview and never given Mr. Deadbeat Dad a second thought. Had she spoken with Landry, she’d probably have…acted really strange and quirky in the interview, but still done well enough. But she spoke with her mother, and acted accordingly. Tyra’s been written as such a weak-willed young woman, she bends her behavior and attitude to accomodate whomever she’s speaking with. She’s a classic appeaser, which makes little sense, as she’s also been shown as the accountable and responsible one in the Collette household. It’s inconsistent and it bugs the hell out of me.
And Tami. Cute and pleading and cajoling and flirty and…Coach has an iron will. I’d have bought the house just to see one of Connie Britton’s smiles. But I do *not* have an iron will.4 What she wanted most of all wasn’t for Coach to buy her the house, but to make the decision *with* her, so his thoughtful, reasoned, emotional explanation ended the discussion on a positive note.
As always, I’m impressed by the maturity and complexity of the Taylor relationship. It’s so nice to see two adults treating each other the way real people do. Theirs is a believable relationship, filled with petty bickering and squabbling, but grounded in open and honest love. It looks real and looks lived-in because it looks like every strong couple you’ve ever seen. It looks like two people who are each other’s rocks.
Other thoughts:
- I thought the quote in the lede was apropos because it fits Jason’s arc a bit, but mostly because while watching I had to laugh at the thought of Tim watching Patti LuPone chewin’ up the scenery in Gypsy. Seriously? Who can’t see Tim sitting there asking “where are the strippers?”
- I’ve never understood Jason’s relationship with Erin. She seemed to go from one-night stand to loving bride-to-be without much intervening relationship building.
- If Jason were ruthless, he’d have brought Wendell in on the condition that he be his agent. Except…Wendell’s a football player and the NFL has very strict licensing guidelines for agents.
- I fear we’ve seen the last of Herc, so let’s all pour one out for our favorite wheelchair-bound homey. *Sigh*. Maybe he’ll buy an orphanage in Dillon and will stay around for awhile.
- I love that real estate agent. I’ve loved her since she came on to Tim back in the pilot. She just cracks me up.
- I’m going to miss Street.
What did everyone else think?
R.A. Porter is an aspiring television writer who currently toils away in the software mines. He can be found at Sketch War, his personal blog, Tumblr, and stalked on Twitter.- Obligatory joke about Kitsch’s dreadful approximation of a Texas accent here: Of *course* he was better silent. [↩]
- It’s good that Tim’s such a natural and dedicated athlete that all the time he misses from the practice field doesn’t impact his game. It’s also good that Coach is so lax about discipline that he doesn’t mind. What the hell? How does Tim even have a spot on that roster anymore?!? [↩]
- An aside: if the Dillon receivers are too stupid to learn the difference between a skinny post and a slant, they deserve the splinters in their asses. I figured the tryout was going to be far more about sharply delineated timing routes, not the patterns that we learn when we’re seven or eight. [↩]
- Or much sense. [↩]
posted by R.A. Porter in → Reviews

November 20th, 2008 at 1:56 am
You know, I hadn't even thought about seeing the last of Herc until you mentioned it here. Good call, that's sad. He was always good for a laugh. I won't forget the great wheel chair fight where Street asks "How do we get back up? Is there some sort of special trick?" and Herc just starts screaming "Phil! Help!"
November 20th, 2008 at 2:33 am
Yeah, that fight was awesome. Herc's always been good for the funny. He's also really been good at keeping Jason grounded.
November 20th, 2008 at 3:07 am
r.a., were you bothered that Street didn't say goodbye to anyone in Dillon other than Riggins? Coach/Street scenes, for example, have been among the best ever in the history of the show. I thoroughly enjoyed the episode as you did. I was pushed over the edge at the point where Riggins takes the wheelchair out of the car and starts his goodbye speech. He says that first line twice – clearly choking up the first time and I wondered whether he truly was choking up and he was doing a retake the second time thinking the first line would be edited out. It was a beautiful blur between acting and reality.
November 20th, 2008 at 3:12 am
Yeah, it was a little bothersome. Clearly Katims and crew thought Jason's full run of episodes contained all the goodbyes it needed, ending with the biggest and saddest one to Riggins, but in the real world he would have said explicit goodbyes right before leaving for NY.
I think the structure of Jason's story tonight – the Midnight Cowboys already in NY – would have been pretty seriously compromised by that. I think we're supposed to assume Jason had a lovely party between last week's episode and last night's.
November 20th, 2008 at 5:25 am
Didn't have time to read your whole recap, I need to go to bed, but I'm with you on the money shot of Riggins at the end…such a moving look on his face and a perfect way to end Street's story on FNL. We'll miss him.
November 20th, 2008 at 8:03 am
Aw, of course Riggins would love the Loops. When does this start on NBC, btw? I'm tired of reading how much everybody else enjoyed themselves watching it.
November 21st, 2008 at 1:51 am
MJ, I wish I could. That blog product we work on is going to be re-done so we'll be like, well, most blogs on the web and it'll be like this where you've really only got to submit name/e-mail/URL (optional). This thing was developed by someone who is no longer with us, so I'll leave it at that, ha.
November 21st, 2008 at 12:52 pm
my initial reaction on Tyra was similar to yours – bugged the heck out of me. But the more I read others' opinions, I'm starting to get swayed by the view that the inconsistency may just be an internal conflict that Tyra is desperately struggling to deal with. Tami can plant all of the seeds to help Tyra get out of Dillon and into a life she can be proud of but she can't get the Collette genes out of Tyra.
@chris – I would also like to post a comment at your FNL blog but I'm not sure it's worth giving up a first-born child to do so. Can't you make those registration procedures go away?
March 7th, 2009 at 4:25 am
Tim Riggins CHOKING UP = solid gold. I don't care about all the mechanics of it — I had to turn off my internal calculator during those cab rides — because emotionally I buy it all. Tyra taking the easy way out again and again, Julie turning into mini-Tami at the dinner table, Coach giving Matt the chance to prove him wrong, the lovely and amazing twists that dream house worked into this marriage — how it let them both be right, and fair, and respectful. Oh, goodbye Street. Nice to see him shine on his way.
December 7th, 2009 at 8:02 am
this is awesome …thanks for your wonderful interests… visit my web and listen to my music, you can also download free tracks
December 19th, 2009 at 6:41 pm
Hey, thanks for your blog, helpful news…